Pin it
This homemade tartar sauce elevates any seafood meal from basic to gourmet with just a few minutes of work. The rich, zesty topping works wonders with everything from battered fish to crab patties, adding that special kick that makes seafood dishes truly stand out.
I threw this tartar sauce together during a family seafood night when our store-bought supply ran out. My hubby said it tasted so much better that we haven't bought the bottled kind in more than 15 years now.
Ingredients
- Mayonnaise: Creates the smooth foundation and adds richness; grab a quality mayonnaise for top-notch results
- Dill pickles: Deliver the essential zing and bits of texture in tartar sauce; go for crunchy ones and chop them small
- Pickle juice: Adds pop and adjusts the thickness just right; don't toss it when finishing your pickle jar
- Minced onion: Brings a gentle sharpness that cuts through the creaminess; try sweet varieties for a gentler touch
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Mix everything together:
- Start with mayonnaise in a small bowl as your foundation. Next, toss in your finely diced dill pickles, making sure they're cut tiny enough to spread well throughout. Add the pickle brine which will both flavor and thin your sauce perfectly. Last, put in your minced onion for that gentle kick that makes homemade tartar sauce so much better.
- Stir everything well:
- With a rubber spatula or regular spoon, blend all components together carefully but completely. Don't forget to run your utensil along the bowl edges and bottom so everything gets mixed in. Keep stirring until you can't see any unmixed parts. You want a smooth mix with tiny green and white flecks scattered throughout.
- Cool it down for better taste:
- Put your finished sauce in a container with a lid and stick it in the fridge for at least 2-3 hours. This waiting period matters because it lets all the flavors blend together and takes some bite out of the raw onions. The sauce will get a bit thicker in the cold and taste more balanced after sitting.
Pin it
Those little dill pickles really make this sauce special. My grandma always told me to chop them by hand instead of using a blender to keep the texture just right. She always said what makes tartar sauce go from good to amazing is those tiny bits of pickle that pop with flavor when you take a bite.
Make It Your Own
Tartar sauce can be changed up easily to suit what you like. Try adding a spoonful of fresh chopped dill or parsley for more layers of taste. Capers work great if you want more salty tang that goes really well with salmon. A little squeeze of fresh lemon really wakes up the whole sauce, while adding a few drops of hot sauce creates a surprising warmth that balances fried food perfectly.
Storage Tips
This sauce will stay good in your fridge for about a week, but it tastes absolutely best between 1-2 days after you make it. Keep it in a glass jar with a snug lid instead of plastic so it won't pick up other food smells. If it gets too thick while stored, just mix in a splash of water or more pickle juice to thin it back to how you like it.
Serving Suggestions
While most folks think of fish and chips first, this sauce works for so much more than that old favorite. Spread it on crab cakes, use it in fish sandwiches, or dunk fried shrimp into it. For something lighter, it makes a tasty dressing on seafood salads. When we have summer barbecues, I always put out a small dish next to the grilled fish for everyone to grab as they please.
Pin it
Try this quick, fresh tartar sauce to make your favorite seafood taste even better!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long does it stay fresh in the fridge?
You can keep homemade sauce in a sealed container in the fridge for up to 7 days. If you wait a day, the flavors really blend nicely for the best taste.
- → Can sweet pickles replace dill?
They sure can! However, using sweet pickles will make it less tangy and add more of a sweet-savory vibe to the flavor.
- → What dishes pair well with this sauce?
It's fantastic with fried seafood like shrimp, fish, calamari, or crab cakes. You can also spread it on fish sandwiches or use it as a dip for fries or fish tacos.
- → Can I skip onions in the sauce?
Sure thing. Either leave them out entirely or swap for green onions or chives for a milder taste. Capers also make a fun alternative for some extra zing.
- → Is there a lighter version available?
Yep! Use part or all Greek yogurt instead of mayo to cut down on the fat and calories while adding some protein. Light mayo is another option.
- → Why is chill time necessary?
Letting it chill for 2-3 hours makes a huge difference! It allows all the flavors to come together and makes the overall taste richer and more balanced. While it’s okay to eat right away, refrigeration really levels it up.