Pin it
Crusty bread topped with gooey cheese and sautéed mushrooms might sound fancy, but it actually comes together super fast. You'll get that umami hit thanks to the mix of mushrooms and cheese, all piled on crisp slices—no need to stress over tricky steps.
One night some friends popped by without warning, and this dish was born. Now every get-together, the crew asks for what they call my “magic mushroom bites”. Can’t blame them—they’re tasty and a breeze to make!
Savory Ingredients
- Baguette: The crunch is key, so get a loaf with lots of crust
- Salt and pepper: These really wake up the flavors—don’t hold back
- Oregano: Adds a hit of Mediterranean taste that blends nicely
- Egg: Helps keep it all wedged on the bread instead of falling apart
- Parmesan cheese: Throws in that sharp, umami flavor
- Mozzarella cheese: Melts into that stretchy, creamy goo we all love
- Mushrooms: The star of the show—try cremini if you want something extra tasty
- Onions: Sweetens things up and balances out those mushrooms
- Butter: Browns the mushrooms and brings everything together
Easy Instructions
- Top Off the Toasts:
- Once everything’s blended, pull your pan off the heat. Grab your lined baking pan, set out the bread, and heap mushroom filling on top. Sprinkle some extra mozzarella if you want more cheesiness.
- Mix in Egg:
- Crack in the egg and keep stirring. It cooks fast—just a minute. You want it holding the mushroom mix together so it spreads on the bread nice and thick.
- Add the Cheese:
- Pour both cheeses into your hot pan. Watch ‘em melt and turn into one delicious mixture—mozzarella goes gooey, parmesan brings the flavor.
- Spice Things Up:
- Time for oregano, salt, and pepper. Oregano makes it a little herby, salt pops out the mushroom taste, and black pepper brings a little kick.
- Let the Onions Join:
- Chopped onions head into the mushrooms now. Sauté everything for another 5 minutes—onions should be nice and soft. Your kitchen’s gonna smell great!
- Mushroom Time:
- Butter goes into your pan on medium until it sizzles. Toss in the mushrooms. Let them brown and shrink—this keeps your toast from going limp later on.
- Prep First:
- Switch the oven on to 350°F. Get your lineup together. Slice your bread diagonally about three-quarters of an inch thick. Chop onions and mushrooms so every bite gets some of each.
Pin it
Mushrooms really bring this dish together. Years ago a chef pal taught me to let mushrooms get caramelized—don’t rush, let them turn deep brown. Turns out, it’s a total game changer for anything from toast toppers to pastas.
Switch It Up
There are loads of ways to riff on this. Swap the onion for garlic or shallots if you’re in the mood. Oregano can take a break for rosemary or thyme—major woodsy vibes. Feeling fancy? A handful of dried, rehydrated porcini bits makes this taste next-level intense.
Leftovers & Warming Up
Your mushroom mix is good for three days if you pack it up tight and keep it cold. It’s smart to hold off on topping the bread until you’re baking. If there’s finished toast left, reheat it in a warm oven (about 325°F) for a few minutes. If you need to microwave, just know the bread gets soft.
Serving Ideas
Bring these out as the opener for an Italian-style meal—pairs great with a light soup or crisp salad. If you’re throwing a party, cut the bread thinner for little bite-sized crostini and bake a few minutes less. Top with parsley for a splash of green, or drizzle a bit of truffle oil over the top if you want to make it a fancy night.
Pin it
You’ll love how this dish feels both simple and a little fancy—honestly, I make it for almost every hangout.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prepare the mushroom mixture ahead of time?
Sure! Whip up the mushroom mix a day early and stash it in the fridge. When you're ready, just spread it on bread and pop them in the oven. It totally takes the stress out of prepping for guests.
- → What mushroom varieties work best for this appetizer?
Go for button or cremini if you want classic flavor. Want to switch things up? Try shiitake, oyster, or wild mushrooms. Each one adds its own fun twist.
- → Can I make these vegetarian or vegan?
They’re already veggie-friendly. For vegan, swap in plant-based butter and cheese, and use one tablespoon cornstarch mixed with two tablespoons water instead of egg to hold it all together.
- → What can I serve with these mushroom toasts?
Pour a crisp white wine or mix up some light cocktails. Serving with olive tapenade, stuffed tomatoes, or a snack board makes for a great spread too.
- → How do I keep the baguette slices from getting soggy?
Toast the bread slices for five minutes first. Also, cook your mushrooms and onions so most of the moisture is gone. That way, you’ll keep them nice and crisp.
- → Can I freeze these appetizer toasts?
The whole toast doesn’t freeze well, but the mushroom topping does. Freeze it for up to three months, let it thaw out, then build and bake when you want.